Hi everyone! I have a question for all of you goat breeders out there.. Have you ever bred a doe to her father? It sounds like it could definitely cause problems to me, if one wasn't careful. But I'm no expert I'm a little hesitant to do it. Here is my dilemma, I have one doeling who I would rather breed to someone other than her father. The doelings father is "boarding" with all of my other girls at my home. It just seems so much simpler just to use the buck I have here than to go bring another buck back here for a month and put him and my one doeling in a seperate pen. But I do want to do what's best for my goats. Is this father to daughter breeding a bad thing? I would only like to breed them together this once (as next year she should be big enough to breed to a very nice neighborhood buck). I just really don't want to end up with babies coming out with three heads, etc. Thank you!
It depends. How well do you know the line that would be doubled up? Have you seen his mom, sisters, kids, etc? You don't end up with 3 headed kids (although I'm weird to think that would be cool if it lived). What you end up doing is intesifying the good and the bad in the line. Such as, I have an oberhasli buck that throws beautiful strong udders but he has no brisket, it's horrible. Now he throws nice briskets on his kids as it doesn't seem to be a dominant gene in his line BUT if I bred one of his doelings back to him, I'm pretty sure that those kids would have the horrible brisket. The strengths of the line can make it worth the risk too. If his mom has a drop dead gorgeous udder, top line, or some other strength worth intensifying in the kids and he doesn't show a terrible fault. (clear as mud huh?)
I tried to be normal once, it was the worst 2 minutes of my life...
Actually Goathiker that's not a bad explanation at all. Father/daughter breeding can be done. Line breeding/inbreeding is often used by breeders to "set" positive traits in a line. It has played a large role in defining breeds and specific lines within breeds. The problem when it is used indescriminately is that it sets bad traits too. So in Goathiker's example, (in very simplified terms) if the offspring got 'bad brisket' from the father and 'bad brisket' from the daughter, then the offspring has no 'good brisket' at all to pass on in it's genetics, so the bad brisket is set.
I realize that what you are really asking is if your doelings offspring will be deformed. There is no perfect answer to that as it depends on the buck's genetics. If he and the daughter do not share any problem areas then yes you could most likely get away with it. It would happen all the time in a wild herd. But then again a wild herd is more harshly culled (by nature) for survivability issues than a domestic herd. I, myself, do not like to see linebreeding/ inbreeding done (in any species) for convenience. But, I also understand that sometimes you have to take what you have and run with it.
Last edited by Used2bmimi; 11-26-2012 at 05:58 AM.
We have done it several times. Linebreeding/inbreeding one time is not going to cause any major problems. Not sure what your sale is for your kids/her kids. We sold our offspring from father and daughter breedings as commercial, or for 4h kids as show wethers.
If the buck you are using has any major faults or issue, your offspring are for sure to carry it. Like weak legs for example. by breeding that buck to an unrelated doe you stand a chance of having stronger legged offspring from a weak legged buck, but if you breed that buck to his daughter, the odds are pretty good you are going to see weak legged offspring. The same is true for a good quality in your buck. So if you like the buck and you don't feel that having the kids linebred so closely will bother your sale of the kids, then I would do it. Well, I have. One year we bred 5 does back to their father. We purchased another buck, but he ended up being to shy and young to breed the does and so we put them with their dad, rather than having them sit open for another year or having to go and buy yet another buck.
We have also done it other years when we just had one buck and didn't want to buy a 2nd buck for just one or two keeper does.
__________________ "I am not a vet, you should always consult a vet when using medications off label."
Raising Fullblood and percentage Boer Goats in the Valley in VA. http://locusthavenboergoats.weebly.com/
Last edited by 20kidsonhill; 11-27-2012 at 12:11 PM.
I personally am not a fan of inbreeding as well, but I must say that accidents do happen sometimes, and we have run into this situation once in the past. It seemed to have no ill effects on the offspring. We have sloved this problem though, as we now only keep one buck [and he's one HAPPY buck now!!]
Goathiker said it very well!
The outcome can be really really good or really really bad. Not with 3 heads or anything bizarre.
Both strengths & weaknesses will be magnified.
But if doe & sire have no glaring faults you should be ok.
Last yr the only buck I had was sire to one. It was easier to just have him cover her. It was more economical.
Kids turned out pretty good.
If you don't think she should be bred to her sire, then don't. You're going to tighten those genetics up alot with a breeding that close. The kids *could* have issues, though quite unlikely, but things such as weakened immune system happens a lot with closely bred or inbred animals, growth issues, etc. Breedings this close should really only be done with a specific goal in mind and the breeder should be ready to cull because those type breedings don't turn out a lot of the time. If it were me and I didn't think she'd cross well on her sire, then no, I would leave her open til I could find a buck that would.
__________________ Kylee at KW Farms Website: http://www.kwfarms.com/ Home to quality AGS/ADGA/NDGA Nigerian Dwarf Dairy Goats Info. on Nigerian Dwarf goat colors/patterns/etc.: Click Here NEW: LIKE US on Facebook KW FARMS
I do agree, it is is a gamble. You have to know, that line of genetics.
I myself ,wouldn't breed that close, as it may be something not worth waiting for, but yet ,if you know what you are breeding, you may get something extraordinary.
It is up to each breeder.