I have both and I really prefer the horned. It's weird, but they seem to be more secure in their 'sense of self' if goats have such a thing. If they were people, I'd say they are more self confident and well adjusted then the goats w/o any horns. That being said, I don't want another horned buck. I don't know if all bucks get a little touchy when you try to take a doe away or not, but I'd prefer that they don't have any extra weapons if that's the way they feel.